Being able to have twisting propagate down a joint chain is a common feature for character rigs. An automated approach over a manual approach might be a quicker and easier solution, however as we'll discuss below might end up presenting problems. A manual method of animating twisting in the other hand while giving exactly what the animator want, is also more work for the animator. There are many ways to setup twisting, each with their own advantages and issues. However, this post won't be about the best solution for twisting, so much as it will be a practical solution for providing the animator with more control over the twist action of the joints by having both an automated and a manual solution.
I've tried many different setups and upon arriving at this solution I found it to be the most stable and practical for when dealing with twisting.
Watch the video demonstrating the setup here.
So let's get started. Before we start lets create a quick setup to try this out. The first thing we will need is a Spline IK driven joint chain.
Next, we will need to make our IK controls. To keep everything simple for now, lets just use empty transform nodes for our controls. As an observation, this step isn't really necessary, we just want to have a way of driving the curve shape to drive the joint's position.
Let's start by making a single joint, group it twice and name the nodes,
GRP_Start_IK, CTRL_Start_IK, jnt_StartCurveDriver
Duplicate the top group and rename the new nodes,
GRP_End_IK, CTRL_End_IK, jnt_EndCurveDriver
Now we can move the corresponding groups to the start and end of the joint chain.
Finally we can select the driver joints and select the curve last, and goto Skin -> Bind -> Smooth Bind
we can then choose the following options
Now, we can drive the Spline IK with our controls. So this will be our starting point.
Notice that we can move and rotate our controls to drive the curve that is driving the joint chain. However, we can't seem to rotate the controls to get twisting. The reason for this is that components, such as the CVs on the curve only represent points in space, and because we don't get normals with curves, we can't get rotation information from the curve points. Now, some of you may be familiar with the Advance Twist Controls setup for spline IK. If not, you can check out the post here that goes over the setup.
The advance twist setup is nice to quickly get twisting with your Spline IK. However, we mentioned that we want to have not only the option to toggle auto twisting on and off, but to also offset the twisting. In addition we will also look at how this new setup will give us a nice solution for a common problem that comes with using the advance twist controls. Lets take a look now at how we can extract the twist from the spline IK solver and give it to the animator to control and give them the option to automate or not the twisting.
Lets start by creating some attributes on our end control to drive the twisting. Lets create an autoTwist and a twistOffset attribute.
We can now start creating and hooking up the math nodes to help us with this setup. The first thing we want to create is a multiplyDivide node to multiply the rotationX (that is our twist axis for our control in this case) of our end control by our autoTwist attribute value. Lets rename this md_autoTwist and hook up our attributes.
Connect CTRL_End_IK.rotateX to md_autoTwist.input1X
Connect CTRL_End_IK.autoTwist to md_autoTwist.input2X
Next we want to create a plusMinusAverage node to sum our twistOffset value to the output of the multiplyDivide node. So lets do that and rename this pma_twistOffset.
Connect md_autoTwist.outputX to pma_twistOffset.input1D
Connect CTRL_End_IK.twistOffset to pma_twistOffset.input1D
Finally, we are ready to connect it to our ikHandle.
Connect pma_twistOffset.output1D to ikHandle1.twist
There we go! So with not a lot of extra work, just 2 extra nodes we get a clean setup for twisting. And that is actually not the best part. I mentioned earlier that this setup would also help solve an issue of the advance twist control. Or with most automated solutions. And that is the flip that occurs at 180 degrees. This problems occurs because of how rotations are being calculated (Euler rotations). This ends up leading us into problems such as Gimbal locking and making the setup fragile if we are relying on any one rotation axis to get our twisting. So as it turns out its not so advance after all! :)
As this is another whole discussion in itself, I'll just leave it at that. For now, be assured that this setup will handle with no problems rotations beyond 180 degrees or -180 degrees for that matter with no problems because of how the spline IK is solving for twisting.
The setup in its current state is an example in which the twist propagates up the joint chain. However, what if we need the CTRL_Start_IK to also be able to control the twisting. To have the twisting propagate down the joint chain. Let's take a look at that.
If we go ahead and use the roll attribute on the ikHandle notice that the entire joint chain rotates. The obvious thing to do is to counter rotate using the twist and we then get the effect the rotation came from the start of the joint chain.
So let's start with that first.
Connect CTRL_Start_IK.rotateX to ikHandle1.roll
Now, for the start control to work with the end control at the same time and for our autoTwist attribute to work on CTRL_Start_IK as well, we will create another multiplyDivide node, we can call this md_autoTwist2.
Connect CTRL_End_IK.autoTwist to md_autoTwist2.input1X
Connect CTRL_Start_IK.rotateX to md_autoTwist2.input2X
To counter rotate we will use a plusMinusAverage node. We will call this pma_twistOffset2. However, we also need to account for whatever twist offset already exists from the CTRL_End_IK.
Connect pma_twistOffset.output1D to pma_twistOffset2.input1D
Connect md_autoTwist2.outputX to pma_twistOffset2.input1D
Connect pma_twistOffset2.output1D to ikHandle1.twist
And we can set the operation to Subtract.
And there it is! Now go and have fun making your joints twist!
I realize although its not too complicated you probably don't want to have to setup it every single time. Hopefully you still were able to understand it so that you could :)
But to speed up the process here's a script to set it up for you. It takes in the start control, the end control, the control object, the ikHandle, and the twist axis for the control rotation (this can be negative as well).
import maya.cmds as cmds def twist(startCtrl, endCtrl, ctrlObj, ikHandle, axis): ''' Create twist control for the spline IK setup startCtrl : node controlling the start of the joint chain endCtrl : node controlling the end of the joint chain ctrlObj : control object to host the twist attributes ikHandle : the spline IK handle axis : the rotation axis for twisting on the controls : "x", "y", "z", "-x", "-y", "-z" ''' # check nodes for node in [startCtrl, endCtrl, ctrlObj, ikHandle]: if not cmds.objExists(node): cmds.error("%s does not exist." % node) # check axis if axis not in ["x", "y", "z", "-x", "-y", "-z"]: cmds.error("Invalid axis.") # check if our twist axis is on the negative side neg = False splitString = axis.split("-") if splitString == "": axis = splitString neg = True axis = ".r" + axis # create new attributes cmds.addAttr(ctrlObj, ln="autoTwist", at="double", dv=1, min=0, max=1, k=True) cmds.addAttr(ctrlObj, ln="twistOffset", at="double", dv=0, k=True) # create nodes for autoTwist and twistOffset autoTwist1 = cmds.createNode("multiplyDivide", n="md_" + ctrlObj + "_autoTwist1") autoTwist2 = cmds.createNode("multiplyDivide", n="md_" + ctrlObj + "_autoTwist2") twistOffset1 = cmds.createNode("plusMinusAverage", n="pma_" + ctrlObj + "_twistOffset1") twistOffset2 = cmds.createNode("plusMinusAverage", n="pma_" + ctrlObj + "_twistOffset2") # connect the end control cmds.connectAttr(endCtrl + axis, autoTwist1 + ".input1X") cmds.connectAttr(ctrlObj + ".autoTwist", autoTwist1 + ".input2X") cmds.connectAttr(autoTwist1 + ".outputX", twistOffset1 + ".input1D") cmds.connectAttr(ctrlObj + ".twistOffset", twistOffset1 + ".input1D") # connect the start control cmds.connectAttr(startCtrl + axis, autoTwist2 + ".input1X") cmds.connectAttr(ctrlObj + ".autoTwist", autoTwist2 + ".input2X") cmds.connectAttr(twistOffset1 + ".output1D", twistOffset2 + ".input1D") cmds.connectAttr(autoTwist2 + ".outputX", twistOffset2 + ".input1D") cmds.setAttr(twistOffset2 + ".operation", 2) # subtract # connect to the ikHandle cmds.connectAttr(startCtrl + axis, ikHandle + ".roll") cmds.connectAttr(twistOffset2 + ".output1D", ikHandle + ".twist") # make changes if the twist axis is on the negative side if neg: invTwist1 = cmds.createNode("multiplyDivide", n="md_" + ctrlObj + "_invTwist1") invTwist2 = cmds.createNode("multiplyDivide", n="md_" + ctrlObj + "_invTwist2") cmds.setAttr(invTwist1 + ".input2X", -1) cmds.setAttr(invTwist2 + ".input2X", -1) cmds.connectAttr(endCtrl + axis, invTwist1 + ".input1X") cmds.connectAttr(startCtrl + axis, invTwist2 + ".input1X") cmds.connectAttr(invTwist1 + ".outputX", autoTwist1 + ".input1X", f=True) cmds.connectAttr(invTwist2 + ".outputX", autoTwist2 + ".input1X", f=True) cmds.connectAttr(invTwist2 + ".outputX", ikHandle + ".roll", f=True)
Hope you guys liked it! Feel free to share!
And to leave any comments or questions!